Redland Bay Homoeopathy and Natural Therapies | Contact Us
Ironbark Homeopathy publishes on this website an E-journal of opinion that includes articles, links and videos without prejudice, defamation intent of the webmaster in the interest of informing people of Australia on the many issues which concern homeopathy and natural therapies.

It is taken that you have read our Disclaimer and Privacy Policy on entering this website

"Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers"
Article 19 UN Declaration of Human Rights to which Australia is a signatory

Breast Screening Should be Scrapped

Michael Baum
guardian.co.uk, Tuesday August 2011

A paper published in the current issue of the British Medical Journal is yet another inconvenient truth that demands a complete and unbiased re-evaluation of our national breast screening programme (NHSBSP). The paper, based on the World Health Organisation (WHO) database, set out to demonstrate that the introduction of screening by mammography in some countries in Europe was associated with a steeper fall in mortality from breast cancer than in neighbouring countries that had delayed offering this service.

To their surprise they discovered that paired neighbouring countries had experienced the same and very welcome fall in breast cancer mortality whether or not screening had been introduced. Furthermore the steepest fall in mortality observed was among the women under 50 who had not been invited for screening in all of the countries taking part in their study. They concluded that the recent downward trend in breast cancer mortality was nothing to do with screening but all thanks to improvements in treatment and service provision.

In 1987 Margaret Thatcher's government published the Forrest report that advocated the establishment of a screening programme for breast cancer. Although the report had languished on the prime minister's in-tray for six months, it was unveiled two weeks before a general election. Sir Patrick Forrest's report was in good faith and based on the best evidence then available. At that time, as professor of surgery at Kings College Hospital, I was tasked with implementing the programme for the south-east of England and was invited to join the NHSBSP governing committee; I resigned about 10 years later.

U-turns do not embarrass clinical scientists, unlike politicians: if the evidence changes then our minds must change. As the national programme began to run its course, two disturbing observations made me begin to question my original support. First, about 10 years after the initiation of the service, updated analyses of the original data set by independent groups in Europe and the US found that the initial estimate of benefit in the reduction of breast cancer mortality was grossly exaggerated.

The next disquieting observation was the huge surge in the incidence of pre-invasive cancer (ductal carcinoma in situ) that was not accompanied by the expected fall in incidence of the invasive stages of the disease.

I argued that the women, invited for screening, should be informed of these facts. The rest of the committee counter-argued that if women became aware of these facts they would refuse their invitations ("nanny knows best").

The original estimate of a 25% reduction in breast cancer deaths can be translated into absolute numbers as follows. In order to avoid one breast cancer death over a 10-year period, 1,000 women have to be screened whereas the more up-to-date number is closer to 2,000. One woman avoiding a breast cancer death in 2,000 is of enormous value but has to be weighed against the risk of over-diagnosis and over-treatment.

In February 2009 a group of 24 experts, which included eight professors of epidemiology and public health from around the world, wrote a letter to the Times, drawing attention to the serious harmful consequences of screening associated with the over-diagnosis of breast cancer leading to an increase in the number of mastectomies. Over-diagnosis implies the detection of small non-palpable tumours that, although looking like cancer under the microscope, do not have the potential to develop into life-threatening disease.

One should note in passing the recent high-profile announcement by the cancer charities about the increasing incidence of breast cancer that was blamed on lifestyle. Most commentators ignored the fact that the most important lifestyle choice contributing to this increase was the acceptance of an invitation for screening.

The new data published in the BMJ now suggests that none of the gratifying fall in breast cancer can be attributed to screening and that the very existence of a NHSBSP should be questioned. Unless there is public pressure for an independent inquiry to challenge the status quo, it will be business as usual for the screening programme. Furthermore the Department of Health has painted itself into a corner and it is no longer a question of scientific debate – the subject has become too politicised by those who like to avoid U-turns at all costs.


It is taken that you have read our Disclaimer and Privacy Policy on entering this website
Copyright © - Redland Bay Homeopathy and Natural Therapies - All Rights Reserved 2022 - Web Design and Maintenance by Onespot Web Integration

Fair Use Notice and Copyright Laws: As a reader of the Redland Bay Homeopathy and Natural Therapies website of Ironbark Homeopathy, you agree that you will not use any material on or accessed via our website in breach of any copyright laws and the Australian Copyright Act. In particular, you agree that you will not copy, publish, disseminate, reproduce (by whatever means) copyright material on or access via our website other than for purposes permitted under Fair Use or Fair Dealing as defined und the Copyright Act of Australia.

This website may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not always have been specificaly authorized by the copyright owner. As a natural person believing I have a right to choose how I will deal with my own health and as a therapist with a stake in the availability of natural therapies, I present material on my website that I believe will assist to inform others about the issues surrounding homeopathy and other natural therapies. I believe this will advance understanding of the politics of health as well as the human, cultural and medical issues bound up with natural therapies. I believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided by Australian law and Section 107 of the US Copyright Law.

Copyrighted material can be removed on the request of the owner.